astronomay.bsky.social
Staff Astronomer @ a place - Exoplanet Atmospheres. All data is good data. Plus Knitting, Stickers, Baking, and other crafty things. Toddler mom. Previously known as @_astronoMay on the other site. ErinMMay.com SiderealStickers.Etsy.com
👤 Joined on 31 agosto 2023
Followers
Following
Total Posts
@astronomay.bsky.socialNot Found
Not Found
Not Found
Not Found
Not Found
fredzannarbor.bsky.social
Not Found
Not Found
Not Found
christmeans.bsky.social
Not Found
Not Found
olsallymae.bsky.social
jameswilliams35.bsky.social
viewsporn.bsky.social
"The author [...] does not have the expertise to verify every technical detail". THEN DON'T FUCKING POST YOUR SHITASS PAPER
Show Postinterestingggg.... paper on the arXiv tonight of a new planet candidate found with and written up entirely by AI, including the caveat, "The author has not independently checked the analyses and does not have the expertise to verify every technical detail." arxiv.org/abs/2610.28575
Show PostIf you’re sent a paper to review, remember that you make choices. Choices of which papers to review and why, choices of which standards to apply and why. Rigorous peer review is one of the bedrocks of our field. Where we, as the reviewing community, draw our lines, is where the lines get drawn.
Show PostThis strikes me as completely unethical and probably should be rejected by the journal editor without review. Part of the responsibility of submitting a paper is checking your analysis to the best of your ability, and there has to be some minimum nonzero value of said checking / ability.
Show Post