In what way is anyone comparing Jewish people to "extinct" people? And what exactly do you mean by "extinct people"?

Show Post

Every single piece of natural land inhabited today has been conquered from someone else at some point. Civilization is gradually moving past conquest and into living together peacefully. Who cares about thousands of years ago?

Show Post

Regardless of that, I do want to understand better where he's coming from. I simply don't get his arguments. At what point should any people be able to say "we're descended from those who had this land thousands of years ago at this particular time period, so therefore it's ours forever"?

Show Post

It kind of undercuts your claimed status as a "Jewish anthropologist", i.e. a serious scientist who studies Jewish history and culture, to refer to those with whom you disagree about the historical record as "Nazi piece of shit". Perhaps try sharing your knowledge without the pejorative.

Show Post

Your comment implies that Native American “land claims” are in any way comparable to Zionism or like people are generally making that comparison and I find it odd and pointless to pretend that level of racism is even worth acknowledging. My comment wasn’t criticizing the claim Zionism is bullshit.

Show Post